Dammit, SPN...

[beanside]

Make up your fucking mind when it comes to John! Either demonize him, or don't, but stop the goddamn waffling.

In Season 1&2, he was a tortured man who loved his boys and did his best.

Sold his soul for Dean? Crawled out of hell to save his boys one last time? Loved his wife so much that he dedicated his life to killing the demon and protecting his boys?

Season 3 was a little bit rough, but then we had Matt Cohen, and awesome BabyJohn. Now, this season has been one long assrape of all the prior ones.

Getting sick of it, people. I'm not quitting the show or anything, but it's making sure that I won't rewatch most of the season.

Comments

[impala1967.livejournal.com]

Don't get me wrong, I love JDM but I've never really liked john. The phone call with Mary had me thinking not about hunting cause in S1 its cannon that he found out about that stuff after her death, so I was wondering if he was thinking about rejoining the army. And memory is subjective ... after Mary died, of course the marriage was going to be the best, not the usual ups and downs.
But I loved that mary gave dean his pie obession :)